4. You're Not Just Arguing - You're Disconnecting | Alisa Stoddard Coaching

4. You’re Not Just Arguing – You’re Disconnecting

Some couples fight. Others go silent.

Either way – conflict without connection just leaves you both feeling more alone.

In this episode, we’ll break down what’s really happening when your arguments go nowhere (or never even start), and how conflict, handled poorly, pushes emotional intimacy even further out of reach.

You’ll learn:

  • Why conflict in your relationship often leads to disconnection
  • The deeper reason you and your wife don’t feel safe talking about the hard stuff
  • One simple perspective shift that can help you stay grounded during tension

If your communication feels stuck, shallow, or combative – this is where things start to shift.

You don’t need to avoid conflict.
You need to know how to use it to build trust – not break it.

Mentioned on the Show

 

Full Transcript

You ever walk into your own house and feel like a stranger?

You’re doing everything “right.” Paying the bills. Staying calm. Not picking fights.

But somehow, there’s still this… distance. The silence. The short replies. The feeling like you’re walking on eggshells.

And maybe you’re thinking, I don’t even know how we got here.

Avoiding Conflict Doesn’t Protect Your Relationship

 

Today I want to talk about something I see constantly with the men I coach—and it’s this:

Avoiding conflict doesn’t protect your relationship. It disconnects you from it.

We’re going to unpack why avoiding the hard stuff actually does more harm than good—and what you can start doing differently if you want to feel close again.

Because if you’ve been quiet to “keep the peace,” but all you feel is distant and resentful—this episode is for you.

Why Men Avoid Conflict

 

Let’s get real about conflict.

Most men I work with don’t avoid it because they’re weak.

They avoid it because they’ve learned—often through years of experience—that conflict ends badly.

Maybe when you brought something up in the past, it turned into a fight. Or she cried. Or she shut down.

Or you felt like nothing you said came out right, so now… you just say nothing.

And listen, I get it. You’re trying to keep things stable. You don’t want to make things worse.

But silence doesn’t solve the problem. It just shifts the burden inward.

The Hidden Cost of Avoidance

 

The pressure builds, but now no one knows what’s really going on—and over time, you become more like roommates than partners.

That’s the cost of avoidance: resentment, distance, and emotional drift.

Client Story: The Quiet That Hurt

 

Let me tell you about a client.

When he first came to me, he was exhausted. He told me, “It’s like I’m always one wrong word away from everything blowing up.”

He thought he was keeping things calm by staying quiet, taking on more around the house, and just “not making waves.”

But what he didn’t realize was that his wife felt completely alone. She thought he didn’t care. That he didn’t want to work on things.

Meanwhile, he thought he was doing the right thing by staying calm and avoiding more conflict.

They were both suffering—but neither one knew how to reach the other.

What Changed: Owning His Side

 

When he started speaking up—not in a defensive or aggressive way, but with clarity and ownership—everything started to change.

He learned how to name what he was feeling without blame.

He learned how to stay present in uncomfortable conversations without shutting down or powering through.

And maybe most importantly—he started taking responsibility for how he was showing up.

That shifted the dynamic almost overnight.

It’s Not About Fixing Her

 

It wasn’t about “fixing” her or making her do something differently.

It was about him learning how to show up as a calm, connected partner—not just a quiet one.

What Most Men Miss

 

This is the part most men skip over.

They think, If I say the wrong thing, it’ll just start a fight, or She’s the one who gets emotional, so what’s the point?

But here’s what I tell every man I work with:

You are responsible for how you show up in your relationship. Not for her reactions. Not for every single problem. But for your part. Your energy. Your tone. Your presence.

Avoidance Is Still a Choice

 

Avoidance is still a choice. Silence is still a pattern.

And if you don’t take ownership of that, you’ll stay stuck wondering why nothing’s changing—while quietly resenting everything.

Taking Responsibility Is Not Taking the Blame

 

Taking responsibility doesn’t mean you take the blame. It means you stop outsourcing your power.

You stop waiting for her to bring it up. You stop hoping things will magically improve.

You stop numbing out, withdrawing, or exploding after weeks of holding it in.

And instead, you start doing the work of showing up differently.

What Taking Responsibility Sounds Like

 

That might mean saying, “I know I’ve been quiet. I don’t want to keep avoiding things—I want us to feel close again.”

Or it might mean learning how to express disappointment or frustration without using it as a weapon.

Lead With Compassion, Not Control

 

This work is not easy—but it is powerful.

When you take responsibility for your half of the equation, everything changes.

Because you stop reacting—and start leading.

And that’s what your relationship needs. Not a perfect man. Not a fixer. Just a steady, grounded leader who’s willing to face the hard things with compassion.

Your Wake-Up Call

 

So if you’ve been avoiding conflict in the name of keeping the peace—but all you feel is disconnection… this is your wake-up call.

You’re not broken. You’re not too far gone.

But you do need to learn a better way to handle hard things—so you don’t keep pushing away the very intimacy you want.

Thanks for listening. I’ll see you next time.

Enjoying the podcast?

 

Don’t miss an episode—follow the show on:

If this episode resonated with you, would you take a moment to leave a review on Apple Podcasts?
It really does help more men find the podcast—and get the support they need.

Think someone else would benefit from this episode?
Send it their way. It might be exactly what they need to hear right now.

Or just copy and paste this link to share:
https://alisastoddard.com/podcast/youre-not-just-arguing-youre-disconnecting/

Want to feel wanted again? I’ll show you what’s getting in the way—and how to change it.